This is something that I've thought a lot about.
Gay Marriage: Where I stand on it, why, and how I came to that conclusion.
First off, I'm mostly for it being legal. But mostly, I want to ban marriage as a government institution and put in it's place Civil/Legal Unions. These things can have the same basic legal benefits as a current marriage. I'm okay with that.
Why? Because though marriage is a sacred institution(to me) between a man, a woman, and God(This being the most important part) Marriage is recognized as a basic right for all humanity in the United States of America. As such, I feel we do not have a legal right to object to gay marriage as a legal institution. BUT I very strongly feel that marriage is sacred. This is where disallowing marriage as a governmental institution comes in. Government interference has long deteriorated the sanctity of this holy ordinance. From making it easier to get divorced and now for the legal battle of whether gays have the right to be married.
(On the divorce thing, I have not done enough research and I don't know enough to say whether or not it's better or worse in the long run but it has definitely cheapened what marriage is in society's view)
Continuing on: I personally feel and there are studying backing this up that children have the best chance of success throughout their lives if they have both a father and a mother in the home. In theory, having 2 parents is better than 1 whether or not they are of the same sex. This is why I would rather see marriage as it is today be allowed for a homosexual couple than completely disbanded as a legal institution with no legal benefits for having a committed partnership. I feel it is better for society in the long run to encourage coming together to form a family rather than single parenthood.
(Don't get me wrong, I know some amazing people that have come from single parent households)
Marriage as a holy institution can and should live on. I have grown up in the Mormon church, we have always held special wedding ceremonies that specifically seal the husband and wife not just to each but to God. It is my belief(not a fact, just an assumption) that most Christian and non-Christian religions already do this. That is why they get married in churches. They want God in their relationship. People already get married in a courthouses or without religious intent this will not change that AT ALL; but here's the thing. In order for this to work there needs to be legal safety for a church to deny performing any marriage in their building. This is scary ground because it does allow the possibility of all kinds of discrimination. Because you have to allow for the right to deny anyone to allow for the sanctity of the marriage in the eyes of not only the couple, but frankly, also the parishioner who performs the marriage.
Here's the problems that I see. There's a lot of semantics involved here. Basically, gay rights activists will have "won." Which some people will have a problem with. Like I said, I feel that legally it has been defined as a basic right so as such cannot be denied.
Gay rights activists might feel like other party wins because we are redefining the legal definition of the words marriage. So technically...they aren't getting married.
My assumption is that the gay couples that wish to invite God into their relationship(which is weird to me but I'm sure it's bound to happen) will find a place that will accept them into their congregation and wed them. If not...well that could be a problem.
Is there anything else that I didn't see? Is this totally crazy? Is it too much of a compromise for both sides? Is it possible it could be deemed as a win win? I would really love feedback here. Share it with whomever you think would find this proposition interesting. It's not perfect, but it works in my head. With my views on life and my compassion for all people to find happiness and success in this life this is what I've come up with; so please, once again, talk about this with me, tell me if I'm crazy. Tell me if I'm smart(this is something I truly approve of)
This is something I've thought about while going along my Grand Adventure.
Gay Marriage: Where I stand on it, why, and how I came to that conclusion.
First off, I'm mostly for it being legal. But mostly, I want to ban marriage as a government institution and put in it's place Civil/Legal Unions. These things can have the same basic legal benefits as a current marriage. I'm okay with that.
Why? Because though marriage is a sacred institution(to me) between a man, a woman, and God(This being the most important part) Marriage is recognized as a basic right for all humanity in the United States of America. As such, I feel we do not have a legal right to object to gay marriage as a legal institution. BUT I very strongly feel that marriage is sacred. This is where disallowing marriage as a governmental institution comes in. Government interference has long deteriorated the sanctity of this holy ordinance. From making it easier to get divorced and now for the legal battle of whether gays have the right to be married.
(On the divorce thing, I have not done enough research and I don't know enough to say whether or not it's better or worse in the long run but it has definitely cheapened what marriage is in society's view)
Continuing on: I personally feel and there are studying backing this up that children have the best chance of success throughout their lives if they have both a father and a mother in the home. In theory, having 2 parents is better than 1 whether or not they are of the same sex. This is why I would rather see marriage as it is today be allowed for a homosexual couple than completely disbanded as a legal institution with no legal benefits for having a committed partnership. I feel it is better for society in the long run to encourage coming together to form a family rather than single parenthood.
(Don't get me wrong, I know some amazing people that have come from single parent households)
Marriage as a holy institution can and should live on. I have grown up in the Mormon church, we have always held special wedding ceremonies that specifically seal the husband and wife not just to each but to God. It is my belief(not a fact, just an assumption) that most Christian and non-Christian religions already do this. That is why they get married in churches. They want God in their relationship. People already get married in a courthouses or without religious intent this will not change that AT ALL; but here's the thing. In order for this to work there needs to be legal safety for a church to deny performing any marriage in their building. This is scary ground because it does allow the possibility of all kinds of discrimination. Because you have to allow for the right to deny anyone to allow for the sanctity of the marriage in the eyes of not only the couple, but frankly, also the parishioner who performs the marriage.
Here's the problems that I see. There's a lot of semantics involved here. Basically, gay rights activists will have "won." Which some people will have a problem with. Like I said, I feel that legally it has been defined as a basic right so as such cannot be denied.
Gay rights activists might feel like other party wins because we are redefining the legal definition of the words marriage. So technically...they aren't getting married.
My assumption is that the gay couples that wish to invite God into their relationship(which is weird to me but I'm sure it's bound to happen) will find a place that will accept them into their congregation and wed them. If not...well that could be a problem.
Is there anything else that I didn't see? Is this totally crazy? Is it too much of a compromise for both sides? Is it possible it could be deemed as a win win? I would really love feedback here. Share it with whomever you think would find this proposition interesting. It's not perfect, but it works in my head. With my views on life and my compassion for all people to find happiness and success in this life this is what I've come up with; so please, once again, talk about this with me, tell me if I'm crazy. Tell me if I'm smart(this is something I truly approve of)
This is something I've thought about while going along my Grand Adventure.